PetFriendly Review: Treats Are Where Pet Weight Goes
PetFriendly delivers monthly pet care subscription boxes containing treats, toys and care products from around $20. It is a pet subscription service with no human health relevance. It gets a proper review because of one specific interaction with something this site has raised repeatedly: a majority of US pets are overweight, treats are a large and uncounted part of why, and a box of them arriving monthly makes that harder rather than easier.
Verified August 25, 2026. PetFriendly sells pet products. Nothing here replaces veterinary advice. For weight-loss medication see our GLP-1 provider rankings.
Affiliate disclosure: Rx Saver Hub earns a commission if you sign up through links on this page. It does not change what we write — see our disclosure policy.
Verdict: Genuine convenience with a mechanism that works against pet weight management. Subscription boxes deliver variety and remove shopping trips, and pets enjoy new toys — those are real benefits. What a monthly delivery of treats does is add calories on a schedule, independent of whether the animal needs them, and treats routinely account for a large share of a pet's daily intake without anyone counting. If your animal is at a healthy weight, that is manageable with adjustment. If it is not, a monthly treat delivery is working against you.
What PetFriendly Costs
Subscription pricing with treats, toys and care products bundled.
| Plan | What you get | Listed | Real cost |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monthly box | Treats, toys, care products | From about $20 | Variety and convenience |
| Treats specifically | Calorie content | Frequently uncounted | Where the problem sits |
| Toys and enrichment | No calorie content | Included | The part without the downside |
| A kitchen scale | For measuring food | Almost free | What actually works |
Count treats toward the daily total, or they undo the portioning
Veterinary surveys consistently find a majority of US dogs and cats are overweight, and the cause is portion size plus treats nobody counts. Treats can account for a substantial share of daily calories, and because they are given in ones and twos across a day they feel like nothing. Ask your vet for a daily calorie figure, work out what the treats you give contribute, and subtract that from meals rather than adding it on top. If a subscription is delivering more treats than your animal's allowance accommodates, that is a reason to pause it rather than to feed them anyway.
The toys and enrichment items carry no calories and no downside. It is the treat component worth managing.
The treat arithmetic nobody does
Meals get measured, at least sometimes. Treats get handed over — for coming when called, for being good, for existing — and each one feels too small to matter.
They are not too small to matter. Guidance generally suggests treats should make up no more than around a tenth of daily calories, and in practice they routinely exceed that considerably, particularly with larger commercial treats given to smaller dogs.
The fix is arithmetic rather than willpower. Get a daily calorie figure from your vet, find out what your treats contain, and deduct them from meals rather than adding them on top.
Non-food rewards work too. Play, attention and praise are genuinely reinforcing for most dogs, and substituting some of the food rewards costs nothing and helps.
Where subscription boxes fit
The toys and enrichment side is the part without a downside. Novelty genuinely helps with boredom-related behaviour, and rotating toys is a legitimate benefit.
The treat side is where the model works against weight management, because delivery is on a schedule rather than tied to what the animal needs.
If your pet is overweight, the sensible options are pausing the subscription, using treats as the whole daily allowance rather than an addition, or breaking them into smaller pieces — dogs respond to the event of receiving a treat far more than to its size.
And for cats specifically, weight loss must be gradual — rapid loss risks hepatic lipidosis, which is serious. Any feline weight plan should be vet-supervised.
The honest reason this is here
This site reviews the brands in the affiliate programmes available to it. Some connect meaningfully to GLP-1 treatment and some do not. Inventing a wellness angle here would be exactly the kind of stretch this site criticises elsewhere, so the review below judges the business on what it actually is. If you came here for weight-loss content, the GLP-1 provider rankings are the page you want.
Pros and Cons
Strengths
- Convenience of monthly delivery without shopping
- Toy and enrichment variety with no calorie downside
- Accessible entry pricing from around $20
- Curated selection removes decision-making
Drawbacks
- No human health or weight-loss relevance
- Monthly treat delivery works against pet weight management
- Treats routinely exceed recommended proportion of daily calories
- Subscriptions accumulate if the pet cannot eat the volume
Who Should Pick It — and Who Shouldn't
Good fit
An owner of a pet at a healthy weight who values variety and will count treat calories toward the daily total.
Look elsewhere
Anyone with an overweight pet. A monthly treat delivery makes portion control harder, and portion control is what works.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I help my overweight pet?
Get a daily calorie figure from your vet, measure meals to it, and count treats toward that total rather than adding them on top. Treats routinely exceed the recommended proportion of daily calories because they are given in ones and twos and feel like nothing.
How many treats can I give my dog?
Guidance generally suggests treats should be no more than around a tenth of daily calories. Work out what yours contain against your vet's daily figure. Breaking treats into smaller pieces works well, since dogs respond to receiving one far more than to its size.
Are subscription boxes bad for pet weight?
The toy and enrichment side has no downside. The treat side delivers calories on a schedule independent of what the animal needs, which works against portion control. If your pet is overweight, pause it or use the treats as the whole daily allowance.
Can cats lose weight quickly?
No — feline weight loss must be gradual, because rapid loss risks hepatic lipidosis, which is serious. Any cat weight plan should be supervised by a vet.
Considering PetFriendly?
Count the treats toward the daily total rather than adding them on top. That is where most pet weight actually comes from.
More Reviews Like This
Other brands we have reviewed in the same category.
Pricing and service model read from petfriendlybox.com on August 25, 2026 and subject to change. PetFriendly sells pet products and has no human medical function. Not a substitute for veterinary care. Rx Saver Hub earns a commission on subscriptions made through links on this page.